I was procrastinating for a few hours and doing what I usually do which is to say, rifle through every blog, forum and online newspaper my fingertips can recall. Self-pay jails (at $82 a night), another bombing in Pakistan, the life and times of Tamara de Lempicka, but it was the following topic in coolrunning that sent me off on a whirlwind tour of sites not usually traveled (by me anyway): Better Peanut Butter?. Thus began my quest to discover more about PB2– an “all-natural” powdered peanut butter with a hefty reduction in fat and calories that has everyone from chowhound to hungrygirl to coolrunning clamoring for more. Not one dissenting opinion which I have to admit made me think twice about taking a second spoonful of my own freshly ground insanely decadent honey roasted peanut butter. Apparently it’s at least 90% if not 100% as good as the real thing.
The company, Bell Plantation, apparently has its roots in agricultural research and evolved into developing peanut-based products to help deal with the 1.2 billion pound peanut crop surplus and help out America’s peanut farmers. An opportunity to satisfy both my pb&j cravings and support the farming economy at 54 kcals per serving? My JetBlue Amex in hand, I was ready to plunge into the powdered PB pool and join the others. I happily registered as a new user and started to fill my cart.
At some point, I stopped to look through the rest of the site– I was curious to know how this masterful peanut butter was really created (to be honest I wondered, if peanut butter could be made to taste like peanut butter with 1/3 the calories and fat, then why hasn’t Skippy or Jif been able to make this leap? Was there some special process or were they just willing to sacrifice a whole lot more peanuts to help drain that surplus.).
Funny thing is: aside from the nutrition panel, I couldn’t find an ingredient list or even a rudimentary description of the peanut butter making process. Even in their FAQs, there was no comment on this. Rummaging through a few other blogs and other media, I found some reference to this being an ‘all-natural’ product, slow roasted and pressed to remove the fat, but from a third party source and it wasn’t even clear where she got her information.
I started to think too much I think. I suppose the feat of creating a low-cal peanut butter that tastes as good as the real-thing is enough. I should be happy about that. But I guess I’m suspicious by nature– if this was just a matter of squeezing the fat out, then why can’t Kraft (Proctor & Gamble) do it just as well?. It began to annoy me that a company that was selling a product to a potentially more nutrition (or at least calorie) aware consumer base would have addressed this issue a little more handily than with a picture that looks it was taken from the 1950’s archives.
I’m making a big deal out of something altogether trivial– part of this is because I am in fact, procrastating- the other part is because well, I’m irritated that most people just seem happy to have found the ‘no-pudge’ of peanut butters. The only problem is, I can’t think of any product for which there is a low-cal variant that tastes like the real thing.
1 Comment so far
Leave a comment
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <pre> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>
I am also skeptical. I haven’t yet tried it but I have spent some time thinking about it.
I think the reason nobody else has marketed something like this lies in why its sold as a powder. I’d imagine everybody else is looking for a spread that is, well, a spread!
Water tends to separate. Sure, so does oil when we have all-natural PB, but not entirely. Its reasonably easy to stir back in. But I think the water would separate significantly more. No sane person would have believed that you could market a powder PB and expect people to actually want to go to the trouble of stirring in their own water. But it turns out you can, although its only mail order at present.
On the topic of “all-natural”, squishing the oil out of something to the point of being a powder could be described as processed. After all, what is refined flour?
Comment by Siege Sunday, 6 May 2007 @ 12:12 pm